Kate Alice Marshall’s What Lies in the Woods is a haunting, beautifully layered thriller that examines childhood trauma, buried secrets, and the heavy cost of truth. It is both a mystery and a meditation on memory, guilt, and the scars both visible and invisible that never fade.
When Naomi Shaw was eleven, she and her two best friends, Cassidy and Olivia, spent one enchanted summer playing their secret “Goddess Game” deep in the woods. It was a world of make-believe and mythology, a place where they felt powerful and free. But the magic turned to horror when Naomi was brutally attacked and stabbed seventeen times. Against all odds, she survived. The girls identified the attacker as Allan Michael Stahl, a suspected serial killer responsible for multiple murders, and their testimony sent him to prison. The three were celebrated as heroes.
Twenty-two years later, the past refuses to stay buried. Stahl dies in prison, and Naomi’s life now defined by lingering fear and emotional scars is shaken once again. Her old friend Olivia is desperate to confess something about what really happened that day. Naomi returns to her hometown, determined to uncover the truth about the attack and about the lies they told. But someone is willing to kill to keep those secrets hidden.
Marshall crafts this story with a dark elegance, blending psychological suspense with the emotional complexity of damaged friendship. The narrative moves between Naomi’s present-day investigation and the fragments of her childhood memories, creating an unsettling rhythm that mirrors the unreliable nature of trauma. As Naomi pieces together her past, the reader is constantly forced to question what is real and what has been rewritten by fear and guilt.
The small-town setting of Chester becomes its own character claustrophobic, secretive, and filled with people who would rather forget. Naomi, flawed and cynical, is a compelling protagonist. She is not a typical victim; she is angry, defensive, and often unlikable, but her voice feels authentic and raw. Her journey is as much about reclaiming her sense of self as it is about uncovering the truth of that terrible summer.
The story’s pacing is deliberate, beginning with a slow burn before escalating into a tension-filled second half. Marshall skillfully interlaces psychological depth with shocking twists that keep readers guessing until the final pages. While one or two reveals may feel predictable, the book compensates with emotional richness and a truly chilling finale that redefines everything Naomi thought she knew.
Fans of character-driven thrillers like Little Monsters or Broken Things will find this story deeply satisfying. Marshall’s prose has a quiet intensity, and her understanding of trauma’s long shadow gives the book a lingering emotional weight. This is not simply a whodunit it is a story about the lies we tell to survive and the truths that refuse to stay hidden.
Final Verdict:
What Lies in the Woods is dark, smart, and deeply immersive. With its mix of psychological tension, emotional honesty, and haunting atmosphere, it stands as one of the most impressive adult debuts of the year. Kate Alice Marshall proves that she can write not just for young adults but for any reader who craves intelligent suspense.
⭐ Rating: 4.5/5
If you enjoy thrillers that explore memory, friendship, and buried trauma with both heart and suspense, this is a must-read for your list.
👉 Grab your copy of What Lies in the Woods here: https://amzn.to/3Kw2u9v
