Lucy Foley’s The Guest List has all the makings of a gripping modern mystery: a remote island off the coast of Ireland, a lavish wedding between two glamorous people, and a guest list full of secrets, lies, and grudges. Winner of the Goodreads Choice Award for Mystery & Thriller in 2020, this novel has captivated readers with its eerie atmosphere and puzzle-like storytelling. But does it truly live up to the hype?
The Story and Setting
The novel takes place on an isolated island where Jules, a successful magazine publisher, is marrying Will, a rising TV star. The setting is moody and cinematic, with crashing waves, limited phone service, and ominous weather that mirrors the tension among the guests. It feels like a stage designed for disaster, where every shadow hides a secret and every toast may conceal a warning.
The narrative unfolds through multiple perspectives: the bride, the plus-one, the bridesmaid, the best man, and the wedding planner. From the very beginning, readers know that someone will die, but Foley withholds the victim’s identity until late in the book. This structural choice is meant to heighten suspense, keeping readers guessing not only who the killer is but also who the target might be.
Strengths of the Novel
What Foley executes brilliantly is atmosphere. The island is claustrophobic yet mesmerizing, reminiscent of classic Agatha Christie setups where the environment itself becomes a character. The tension builds slowly, layer upon layer, as resentments, jealousies, and old wounds bubble to the surface. Readers who enjoy paying close attention to details will find themselves scanning every line for clues.
Some reviewers highlight the slow-burn structure as a strength. The gradual revelations, the toxic camaraderie among the groomsmen, and the subtle hints dropped in dialogue all contribute to an ending that, while shocking, feels inevitable in hindsight. When the lights go out and a scream pierces the night, the payoff is undeniably cinematic.
Where It Falters
At the same time, The Guest List is not without its flaws. A recurring critique is that the cast of characters, though well-drawn, is largely unlikable. From the controlling and image-obsessed bride to the cocky groom and his crude school friends, most of the guests are deeply unpleasant people. For some readers, this adds realism and complexity. For others, it makes the book an exercise in endurance.
Another sticking point is pacing. For more than half the novel, little actually happens beyond petty conflicts, drunken confessions, and cryptic reflections. While this tension is supposed to heighten the suspense, some readers felt that it dragged and diluted the eventual impact. When the murder is finally revealed, the connections and coincidences behind it struck certain readers as too convenient rather than jaw-dropping.
Overall Impression
The Guest List is a novel that thrives on mood and setup. It captures the allure of a locked-room mystery in a modern, glitzy package. For readers who love atmospheric thrillers and don’t mind a slow buildup, this book delivers a satisfying escape into a stormy Irish night filled with secrets. For those who prefer fast-paced storytelling or more likable characters, it may feel overlong and less rewarding.
Despite its divisiveness, Foley’s novel is undeniably effective in creating tension and atmosphere. It is easy to see why it won the Goodreads Choice Award, even if not every reader walks away equally impressed. If you enjoy mysteries where the setting itself feels like a trap and every character harbors a dangerous secret, The Guest List deserves a spot on your reading list.
Final Verdict
A stylish, atmospheric whodunit that balances suspense with drama, The Guest List succeeds more as a mood-driven mystery than a character-driven one. It may not shock every reader, but it keeps you turning pages until the very end.
📖 Get your copy of The Guest List here: Buy on Amazon
