Samuel Burr’s The Fellowship of Puzzlemakers is a charming, bittersweet novel that celebrates eccentricity, love, and the lifelong quest to find where we belong. Combining gentle humor with heartfelt emotion, Burr weaves a story about a young man raised by an extraordinary group of puzzle-obsessed geniuses, and the journey that forces him to piece together the greatest mystery of all: his own life.
At the center of the novel is Clayton Stumper, an endearing oddball who dresses like an old man and drinks sherry like a spinster aunt. Abandoned as a baby on the steps of the Fellowship of Puzzlemakers, Clayton grows up surrounded by a collection of Britain’s sharpest minds codebreakers, cruciverbalists, maze-makers, and inventors who have turned their shared love of puzzles into a way of life. When Pippa Allsbrook, the Fellowship’s founder and Clayton’s beloved guardian, passes away, she leaves behind one final challenge: a puzzle that promises to reveal the truth about his parentage.
The narrative unfolds across two timelines. One follows Clayton in the present day as he unravels the riddles Pippa left behind, embarking on a quiet but profound adventure that takes him from the cozy halls of the Fellowship to the wider world beyond. The other transports readers into Pippa’s own past, revealing how the Fellowship came to be and the complicated, tender bonds that grew among its members. This dual structure gives the novel its emotional weight, showing how love, friendship, and intellectual curiosity can form the backbone of a chosen family.
Burr’s writing shines most in his depiction of these misfit geniuses. Each member of the Fellowship from the jigsaw artist to the trivia expert to the kindly but chaotic housekeeper feels alive with quirks and contradictions. They argue, bicker, and banter, yet underneath it all lies a deep affection that binds them together. For readers who love stories about found families and eccentric communities, this novel feels like a warm, slightly dusty hug.
Where the story falters is in pacing. Some readers may find that the second half meanders, with moments that feel more like polite conversation than forward motion. Clayton’s character, though sweet and sincere, can seem passive at times, and the romance subplot doesn’t quite have the spark to match the emotional depth of the Fellowship scenes. Still, Burr’s compassion for his characters keeps the story afloat, and the themes of belonging and self-discovery resonate beautifully.
What’s especially clever is how Burr incorporates actual puzzles into the narrative. Readers can, if they choose, pause and solve some of them alongside Clayton. The puzzles themselves are not especially complex, but they serve as metaphors for life’s larger riddles how we make meaning out of chaos, and how connection can be both the problem and the answer.
Ultimately, The Fellowship of Puzzlemakers is less about solving crosswords and more about solving the mysteries of the heart. It’s about grief and growth, about the families we build for ourselves when life doesn’t go according to plan. Burr’s gentle humor and affection for his oddball characters make this a tender, uplifting read for anyone who has ever felt out of place in the world.
Final Verdict: A touching and quietly whimsical debut that celebrates intellect, kindness, and the strange beauty of community. Perfect for fans of The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry or Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine.
👉 Grab your copy here: Buy on Amazon
