If you’ve ever wondered what it would feel like to get trapped inside a video game dungeon, Matt Dinniman’s The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook delivers that experience in a way that is both hilarious and surprisingly heartfelt. This is the fourth book in the wildly popular Dungeon Crawler Carl series, and it proves once again why Dinniman has such a loyal following among LitRPG fans.
This time, Carl and his unlikely crew including Donut the cat find themselves in The Iron Tangle, a floor designed as a twisted subway system made from real-world underground railways tied into one giant knot. It is disorienting, chaotic, and filled with monsters at every turn. Up feels like down, and safety is always just one stop away but never close enough. The setting alone provides a clever and mind-bending backdrop that makes this installment stand out.
What keeps readers hooked is not just the dungeon mechanics, but the way Dinniman balances absurd humor with raw emotion. The dialogue feels authentic, often sounding like something you would overhear at a bar, in a gaming session, or from a sleep-deprived friend. Carl’s narration is refreshingly real, capturing both his sarcasm and his exhaustion in ways that feel deeply human, even when surrounded by chaos.
The book also introduces The Anarchist’s Cookbook, a legendary tome filled with crafting recipes, survival tips, and the voices of crawlers who came before. It adds an extra layer of mystery and continuity to the series, making the world feel bigger and the stakes even higher. Fans who love RPG elements will enjoy the details of base-building, enchantments, bounties, and new class mechanics that expand the possibilities of dungeon life.
As always, Donut the cat steals the show. Equal parts comic relief and emotional anchor, she embodies both childlike innocence and sharp wit. The banter between her and Carl is one of the strongest aspects of the series, balancing the grim battles with laugh-out-loud moments.
Not every reader will love the heavy train motif of this particular dungeon. If you are someone who finds subway maps confusing in real life, you might feel the same here. Still, Dinniman’s inventiveness ensures that the floor never feels repetitive, and the emotional payoffs especially toward the end more than make up for any slower stretches.
Trigger and content warnings are worth noting: this book includes violence, gore, slavery, grief, addiction references, and other darker themes. Dinniman does not shy away from difficult material, but he handles it with the same mix of humor and gravity that defines the series.
Final Thoughts
The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook is chaotic, funny, and unexpectedly moving. It is video-game popcorn at its finest, offering clever mechanics, unpredictable monsters, and characters who continue to grow in depth and relatability. If you’ve been following Carl and Donut since the beginning, this book is another addictive ride. And if you’re new to the series, it’s proof of why this LitRPG phenomenon keeps leveling up.
👉 Get your copy of The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook on Amazon here
