Christopher Buehlman’s The Blacktongue Thief is an exhilarating plunge into a dark, witty, and vividly alive fantasy world. With sharp humor, raw emotion, and cinematic worldbuilding, this novel marks Buehlman’s triumphant transition from horror to high fantasy. It is the first book in the Blacktongue trilogy, yet it stands on its own as a fully realized adventure.
At its heart is Kinch Na Shannack, a charming rogue who owes a small fortune to the Takers Guild for his education as a thief. His “curriculum” included lock-picking, knife-fighting, wall-scaling, trap-making, and a bit of magic skills that have kept him alive but also in perpetual debt. When he attempts to rob a lone traveler on a forest road, Kinch soon discovers he has chosen the worst possible target: Galva, a battle-hardened knight and handmaiden of the goddess of death. Their fates entwine, leading them on a perilous journey through a world scarred by goblin wars, haunted by krakens, and stalked by giants.
Buehlman’s storytelling is a masterclass in tone and pacing. As Robin Hobb noted, The Blacktongue Thief hits every essential mark complex characters, a compelling plot, rich worldbuilding, and a magic system that feels both organic and mysterious. Yet it also transcends these fundamentals. The humor is dry and biting, perfectly balanced with emotional depth and moments of genuine tenderness. Kinch’s first-person narration brims with self-deprecating wit, streetwise insight, and a voice so distinctive that readers will instantly fall under his spell.
The book’s greatest strength lies in how effortlessly Buehlman blends levity with darkness. This isn’t a comedy, though it’s often laugh-out-loud funny. Beneath the jokes and banter lies a story about loyalty, survival, and the cost of freedom. There are grim battles, haunting revelations, and flashes of heartbreaking vulnerability that elevate the story beyond mere entertainment. As Mark Lawrence observed, Buehlman’s humor feels entirely of the world rather than imposed upon it a rare feat in modern fantasy.
The magic of The Blacktongue Thief is deliberately soft-edged, unpredictable, and bursting with imagination. Instead of rigid systems, Buehlman gives us a sense of mystery and awe that harkens back to the classics. Enchanted tattoos, dangerous cards games, and sea voyages teeming with menace keep the reader immersed from start to finish. Even when the pacing slows during the middle section, the vivid dialogue and rich cultural details more than make up for it.
Kinch himself is one of the most endearing fantasy protagonists in recent memory irreverent, cunning, and occasionally poetic. His blind cat companion adds a touch of eccentric charm that fans of Kings of the Wyld or The Lies of Locke Lamora will appreciate. The novel’s final act is a thrilling crescendo, full of tension and heart, leaving readers both satisfied and eager for the next installment.
With its perfect balance of grit, humor, and imagination, The Blacktongue Thief proves that Christopher Buehlman is not only a gifted storyteller but a genuine force in modern fantasy. This is a book that will steal your heart while keeping a dagger pressed to your ribs.
Verdict: 5/5 – Darkly funny, thrillingly original, and impossible to put down.
👉 Grab your copy of The Blacktongue Thief here: https://amzn.to/4pP6ySa
