Natalie Guerrero’s My Train Leaves at Three is a bold and emotional debut that captures the grit, rhythm, and ache of chasing a dream in New York City. It’s a coming-of-age story that hums with honesty and heat, following a woman caught between ambition and self-destruction, faith and freedom, performance and authenticity.
What it is about
Xiomara, an Afro-Latina actress and singer from Washington Heights, is nearly thirty and feels stuck in a loop of disappointment. Her sister’s sudden death has left her hollow, and her life is a string of underpaid jobs, dead-end relationships, and a mother whose Catholic devotion feels suffocating. She spends her mornings serving pancakes to tourists while singing show tunes and her nights wondering when her own spotlight will finally arrive.
When an unexpected audition with Manny Santos, a celebrated Broadway director, offers her a shot at the life she’s always dreamed of, Xiomara grabs it with both hands. But as the promise of success turns into a trap of manipulation and moral compromise, she’s forced to ask herself what she’s willing to lose in the name of ambition. In the background, Santi, a kindhearted coworker, becomes an unexpected reminder that real connection might still be possible, even as fame looms like a mirage.
Why it stands out
Guerrero’s writing is vibrant, sharp, and full of rhythm. Her prose swings like jazz improvised yet controlled, pulsing with emotion. She brings New York to life not as a glamorous dreamscape but as a living, breathing city of contradictions: where hope and despair share the same cramped apartments and where applause can sound a lot like warning sirens.
What makes My Train Leaves at Three especially powerful is its unflinching portrayal of grief and survival. Xiomara is messy, cynical, and heartbreakingly real. She makes bad choices and owns them. She lashes out, then softens. She’s the kind of heroine who refuses to fit neatly into the boxes that fiction often reserves for women of color. Her vulnerability and pride coexist, making her feel wholly alive.
Guerrero also explores the darker side of the entertainment industry the exploitation that hides behind charm, the emotional toll of constant comparison, and the seductive nature of being seen. Through Xiomara’s story, she asks what it means to stay true to yourself in a world that constantly tries to reshape you.
Themes that linger
This novel dances between grief, identity, religion, and female ambition. Guerrero writes about the loneliness of loss, the cost of assimilation, and the hunger to be both loved and respected. At its heart, My Train Leaves at Three is about learning that moving forward isn’t always the same as moving on.
Notable lines
“It’s always this way with men. I give you this if you’ll give me that.”
“When I finally make it to the audition, everyone looks just like me but better.”
“America is obsessed with dead girls. It’s sickening really, the idea that we are so much more valuable dead than alive.”
Each quote reveals Guerrero’s ability to slice truth out of the ordinary. Her sentences sting and sing at the same time.
Final thoughts
My Train Leaves at Three is a fierce, lyrical debut that shines with authenticity. It’s a love letter to flawed dreamers, a critique of the systems that exploit them, and a story about rediscovering your own voice after losing everything. Natalie Guerrero delivers a novel that feels like a standing ovation and a gut punch all at once.
Verdict: Raw, rhythmic, and emotionally charged. A must-read for anyone who’s ever chased a dream and wondered if the price was too high.
👉 Grab your copy here: Buy on Amazon
