An Honest but Imperfect Reckoning with Faith, Family, and Freedom
“Counting the Cost” is a memoir that dares to pull back the curtain on one of America’s most famous fundamentalist families. Written by Jill Duggar, her husband Derick Dillard, and Craig Borlase, this book marks the first time Jill steps forward to tell her unfiltered truth about life inside and beyond the Duggar empire. As a former star of TLC’s 19 Kids and Counting, Jill grew up under the constant gaze of cameras and an even more rigid gaze of religious control. What unfolds in this memoir is both deeply personal and socially revealing.
At its heart, “Counting the Cost” is not a “tell-all” in the traditional sense. Readers looking for sensational gossip or explosive confessions will be disappointed. Instead, the book’s tone is restrained and sincere, revealing the emotional cost of obedience, family loyalty, and religious indoctrination. Jill recounts her years of being the dutiful daughter, bound by patriarchal rules that defined her clothing, her career, and even her autonomy after marriage. The memoir traces her awakening to the realization that love and loyalty do not have to mean submission and silence.
Elizabeth, a former IBLP (Institute in Basic Life Principles) daughter herself, beautifully summarized Jill’s emotional arc: this is “the book Jill had to write.” The details about her father’s control, her first small act of rebellion in wearing pants, and the painful process of setting boundaries will resonate deeply with readers who have lived under similar systems of authority. Through Jill’s voice, we witness both the cost of estrangement and the cost of freedom.
Yet, the book’s limitations are equally evident. As Emily Ann Page points out, “Counting the Cost” feels cautious, perhaps necessarily so. Jill chooses not to delve too deeply into her brother’s abuse scandal, nor does she publicly criticize her mother, Michelle Duggar, whose silent complicity looms in the background. This restraint can be frustrating, but it also reflects Jill’s complex humanity a woman still navigating her own boundaries between faith, family, and self-preservation.
The writing itself is simple, straightforward, and far from literary, but that might be its strength. It allows Jill’s authenticity to shine through the pain and confusion. The memoir quietly exposes a larger intersection between religious authoritarianism, media exploitation, and family power dynamics. Jill’s journey through therapy, her acknowledgment of an “inner critic,” and her measured steps toward independence feel genuine and hard-earned.
However, not all readers found healing in her words. Bookishrealm’s review offered a strong counterpoint, criticizing the lack of true deconstruction in Jill and Derick’s worldview. While the book exposes control and abuse within the Duggar household, it simultaneously reveals lingering biases, particularly in the couple’s missionary work and Derick’s public behavior. This contradiction makes “Counting the Cost” a memoir of partial liberation rather than full transformation.
Still, to dismiss the book entirely would be to overlook the courage it took to write it. Escaping a lifetime of indoctrination is never neat or immediate. For Jill, this memoir is both testimony and therapy a first step rather than a final declaration. It gives a voice to countless others raised in high-control religious environments and opens an important cultural dialogue about faith, autonomy, and truth-telling.
In the end, “Counting the Cost” is a mirror for anyone who has wrestled with family expectations, faith-based guilt, or the painful process of defining one’s own identity. It is flawed, brave, and necessary.
Verdict: 4/5 – Honest, moving, and imperfect, but a valuable glimpse into the hidden realities behind America’s most famous Christian family.
👉 Purchase “Counting the Cost” on Amazon: https://amzn.to/4h2fBeo
