In Rachel Gillig’s One Dark Window, the mist-locked kingdom of Blunder breathes like a living thing, full of secrets, decay, and shadow. With lyrical prose and gothic undertones, Gillig crafts a story where the line between salvation and damnation blurs and where the real monster might live inside the heroine’s own mind.
Elspeth Spindle has survived this cursed world by making an uneasy pact with the voice that whispers in her head, an ancient spirit she calls the Nightmare. He protects her, but his power is hungry. When she crosses paths with the mysterious highwayman Ravyn Yew, her life takes a sharp, perilous turn. Together, they embark on a dangerous mission to collect twelve Providence Cards, each imbued with dark magic and each key to curing the corruption that plagues Blunder. But the deeper they delve, the closer Elspeth gets to losing herself to the cards, the magic, and the Nightmare within.
The magic system in One Dark Window is one of its standout features. The Providence Cards function almost like enchanted tarot, each carrying a price that echoes the novel’s central theme: nothing comes without sacrifice. Gillig’s descriptions are atmospheric and eerie, her forested world dripping with fog, secrets, and superstition. There’s a whisper of Venom meets Crimson Peak here equal parts intimacy and dread.
The romance between Elspeth and Ravyn divides readers, and understandably so. For some, their relationship feels tender yet fevered, a slow burn lit by danger and devotion. For others, it leans too heavily on physical attraction without the emotional depth to sustain it. Ravyn, however, steals scenes with his quiet protectiveness and sharp-edged loyalty. It’s easy to see why readers swoon over his brooding intensity and his fierce belief in Elspeth’s strength.
Not every element lands perfectly. The worldbuilding, as some readers have pointed out, can feel underexplored its cultures, traditions, and settings more hinted at than realized. The naming conventions (Blunder, Ravyn, Jespyr, Alyx) sometimes pull you out of the story rather than immersing you deeper. And while the novel juggles multiple threads dark forests, sentient mists, magical illnesses, ancient curses, and court politics not all of them receive the same attention or payoff.
Still, where One Dark Window truly succeeds is in tone. It feels like reading a dream that’s beginning to curdle into a nightmare. The tension between Elspeth and the entity within her is electric, their inner dialogues balancing menace and dark humor. The Nightmare’s presence elevates the story beyond a typical romantasy, grounding it in the psychological: what does it mean to lose yourself piece by piece in exchange for power, love, or safety?
By the end, when Elspeth’s fate intertwines with that of the legendary Shepherd King, the story leaves readers both haunted and hungry for more. It’s not a perfect book, but it’s a captivating one lush, eerie, and unforgettable. Fans of For the Wolf, Uprooted, and Belladonna will find themselves right at home in Gillig’s shadowed woods.
Verdict: One Dark Window is a beautifully sinister tale about identity, sacrifice, and the monsters we carry inside. Whether you fall for its gothic charm or find yourself questioning its choices, it’s a story that will linger in your mind like mist on glass.
👉 Get your copy on Amazon: https://amzn.to/42uIiea
